Homemade Peanut Butter

Homemade Peanut Butter

Jump to Recipe
Print Recipe

I know, I know…I can buy peanut butter at the store :). But, there are a few things that bother me about store-bought peanut butter. The first is that many of them contain palm oil (and many other oils) in them, which are not really all that good for you. To get away from this, I would buy the ‘natural’ peanut butters. The issue with ‘natural’ peanut butter is that it is pure liquid on the top, and hard as a rock on the bottom. “But you need to stir it!” they say. So stir I do. And with 1 mm of head space, I end up getting liquid all over my counter as I carefully try to stir it. I have even tried turning the container upside down and letting it sit on my counter for a few days to see if the oil will go back up into the peanut butter and it doesn’t. So to avoid all of these issues, I finally just made my own. Homemade peanut butter doesn’t contain any unhealthy oils in it, it stirs nicely, and it tastes better than store-bought! I also like that it comes together in about 5-10 minutes, depending on the power of your blender. You can have this peanut butter on a slice of toast, you can eat it out of the jar, or you could use it in my no bake peanut butter coconut and oatmeal cookies or my no bake peanut butter oatmeal granola bars! The possibilities are endless! 🙂

What type of peanuts do I use to make homemade peanut butter?

It’s best to use unsalted, shelled, dry roasted peanuts. Since the peanuts are already roasted, you don’t have to do this yourself! You can also purchase raw, shelled peanuts and roast them yourself (350F for 10 minutes, or until they are lightly golden and glossy with oil).

Can I make homemade nut butters with other nuts?

Yes! Popular alternatives include pistachios, cashews, almonds, sunflower seeds, etc. You can substitute them 1:1 in this recipe.

How long can you keep homemade peanut butter?

Once it’s opened, about six months or so. Homemade peanut butter contains shelf stable ingredients, which is why it lasts so long. However, I always tend to err on the side of caution. I store my peanut butter in the refrigerator, and I make it in small batches so that I can use it within a month or two. You can also freeze it for later use.

What is the main ingredient in peanut butter?

Peanuts! Peanuts are the main ingredient in peanut butter. It can also be your only ingredient. However, I like to add in a healthy oil to make it a little creamier, some honey or maple syrup to make it a little sweet, and a pinch of salt to balance the sweetness.

Can you lose weight by eating peanut butter?

Yes! Peanut butter is high in protein, and low in sugar. It is on the high side as far as calories are concerned, but it is a great food to help keep you fuller, longer, because of its protein content.

What is the healthiest peanut butter?

The healthiest of any food is always going to be the one you make at home. Why? Because you know exactly what went into it, and you have more control over its nutritional profile (i.e., you can add in less sugar, salt, etc.).

How to Make Homemade Peanut Butter

1. Place peanuts in a blender or food processor. Pulse a few times until the peanuts are coarsely chopped. If you want to make chunky peanut butter, take out a quarter of the nuts (the amount of peanuts you put in, divided by 4. So if you put in 1 cup of peanuts, you would set aside 1/4) and set aside.

Shelled, unsalted, dry roasted peanuts sit in a blender container on a blue background. Coarsely chopped peanuts sit in a blender container on a blue background.

2. Run your blender continuously for 30-60s. Stop the blender, open the lid, and scrape down the sides with a spoon. At this point, your peanut butter will resemble couscous.

Finely chopped peanuts sit in a blender container on a blue background. The mixture resembles couscous.

3. Run your blender continuously for 30-60s. Stop the blender, open the lid, and scrape down the sides with a spoon. At this point, your peanut butter will start clumping together.

The beginning stages of homemade peanut butter in a blender container on a blue background. The peanut butter is just starting to clump together.

4. Run your blender continuously for 30-60s. Stop the blender, open the lid, and scrape down the sides with a spoon. At this point, your peanut butter will look thick and glossy.

Thick and glossy homemade peanut butter in a blender container on a blue background.

5. Add in any extras like sweetener, salt, oils, cocoa powder, etc. Run your blender continuously for 1-2 minutes, or until the peanut butter is smooth. While the peanut butter will be more gritty than store-bought, it should be spreadable. The more powerful your blender is, the less gritty it will be.

Kosher salt being added to homemade peanut butter in a blender on a blue background. Maple syrup being added to homemade peanut butter in a blender on a blue background. Extra light olive oil being added to homemade peanut butter in a blender on a blue background.

ARE YOU MAKING THIS RECIPE OR OTHERS?
Share your creations with me by posting a photo on my Facebook page, share it on Instagram, share it on Twitter, or save it to Pinterest with the tag #thepanickedfoodie.

Homemade peanut butter in a small mason jar on a white marble background. A cup of peanuts, extra light olive oil in a small glass dish, maple syrup in a small glass dish, and a 1/4 teaspoon of Kosher salt sit nearby. Peanuts are also sprinkled about.
5 from 5 votes
Print

Homemade Peanut Butter

This homemade peanut butter is so much tastier and healthier than store-bought peanut butter, and it comes together in less than 10 minutes!

Course Base Foods
Cuisine American
Keyword homemade peanut butter
Prep Time 10 minutes
Total Time 10 minutes
Servings 8 tablespoons
Calories 90 kcal
Author The Panicked Foodie

Ingredients

  • 1 cup shelled, unsalted, and dry roasted peanuts
  • 1/4 teaspoon Kosher salt
  • 2 teaspoons honey
  • 1 teaspoon extra light olive oil

Instructions

  1. Put peanuts into a blender and pulse a few times until coarsely chopped. If you want to make chunky peanut butter, measure out 1/4 cup chopped peanuts and set aside.

  2. Run your blender continuously for 30-60s. Stop the blender, open the lid, and scrape down the sides with a spoon. At this point, your peanut butter will resemble couscous.

  3. Run your blender continuously for 30-60s. Stop the blender, open the lid, and scrape down the sides with a spoon. At this point, your peanut butter will start clumping together.

  4. Run your blender continuously for 30-60s. Stop the blender, open the lid, and scrape down the sides with a spoon. At this point, your peanut butter will look thick and glossy.

  5. Add in any extras like sweetener, salt, oils, cocoa powder, etc. Run your blender continuously for 1-2 minutes, or until the peanut butter is smooth and spreadable.

Recipe Notes

  • I made this peanut butter using a magic bullet which I wouldn't recommend. While it can be done, it's easiest to do this in a real blender or food processor.

Credit: The Panicked Foodie

Get my latest posts in your inbox!
Homemade Peanut Butter


9 thoughts on “Homemade Peanut Butter”

  • Great info on peanut butter. I have been gorging on some for so long without knowing much about it. Thanks for letting me know that its low on sugar:)

  • I love peanut butter although I actually buy from the store. And it’s not always good since at times it’s never as smooth. So when it comes to preparing peanut butter, that sounds awesome. I think I should try this.

  • It’s great to have a recipe that you know doesn’t have any of that nasty additives in it! I have never made my own but your recipe makes it so simple I’ll have to give it a go.

    Jackie – Organised Mum Life

  • It is better for you to make and consume homemade products instead of just heavily relying on the convenience of picking them up in the store. When we make our food, we know it’s all natural and healthy without added artificial ingredients, preservatives or fillers. I’d love to make homemade peanut butter myself.

  • Wow! I never knew you could freeze peanut butter! I love this concept of making your own, it seems so many of the store-bought peanut butters have so many preservatives in them – I wonder if that is one of the reasons there are so many allergies lately? If I had a food processor, I would definitely give this a try. Actually, now that I think about it – I’m going to put a food processor on my wish list and save this recipe 🙂

  • I’ve always wondered how to make my own at home. I need to try it sometime. It sounds healthy and delicious!

  • Not crazy about peanut butter but I do buy the organic ones that cost a small fortune lol. The only ingredients ar things you can pronounce and find in stores. However, where I come from, we do grind peanuts into paste and make them into groundnut soup. Delish!

  • I’m glad I happened by because I thought I was the only one who put my peanut butter in the refrigerator!! I love homemade peanut butter. I never thought to make it with pistachios!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


28 Shares
Pin24
Share4
Tweet
+1
Reddit